Who won Survivor 44? Fans react to that massive three-hour finale (2024)

After weeks of wondering, we finally have a victor of Survivor season 44 — and it's not who we thought it would be.

Wednesday night's episode was an extended three-hour finale featuring the final five of the Survivor season 44 cast: Yam Yam Arocho, Carolyn Wiger, Carson Garrett, Heidi Lagares-Greenblatt and Lauren Harpe had to finish puzzles, start fires, plead to the jury and cry their way to the title of sole survivor and that $1 milliongrand prize.

Naturally, with puzzles involved in the first immunity-slash-reward challenge, we already knew that Carson — who had been practicing the game's famous jigsaws back home prior to arriving at the island — would easily take that first comp, granting him not only immunity and a direct spot in the final four but also a feast at the Sanctuary complete with spaghetti, carrot cake and Yam Yam, whom he invites to join.

It was at the Sanctuary that Carson and Yam Yam started strategizing who to knock out next, with their longtime ally Carolyn's name coming up from the latter. "I think between Carolyn and Lauren, Carolyn is the biggest threat... she wants us to believe that she's not in control but she knows exactly what she's doing," Yam Yam said. However, the Tika Three remained intact going into the final five Tribal Council, during which Lauren was ultimately voted out and sent to the jury.

The final four then had to take on the last immunity challenge of the season, Simmotion, one of the franchise's most infamous comps in which players have to catch balls flying out of a metal chute with one arm tied behind their backs. Heidi comes out the winner, securing her spot in the final three of the season.

Even more, Heidi manages to make fire the fastest of not only the remaining players this season but of Tribal Council history, at three minutes and two seconds. Alas, that knocked out Carson from the game, leaving Heidi, Yam Yam and Carolyn to go in front of the jury as the top three and plead their individual case.

And after a majority vote of seven from the jury, it was Yam Yam — not the fan-favorite Carolyn — who ended up the sole survivor, with Heidi coming in second place with one vote. Carolyn did not receive any votes, a fact that shocked viewers at home.

Yam Yam's win marks the first LGBTQ+ Survivor winnersince Todd in season 15back in 2017, and the first queer winner of color in franchise history.

Fans react to the tribe member who won Survivor 44

All episodes of Survivor season 44 are available to stream on Paramount Plus.